Conversations That Matter: Responses to Life-Limiting Prenatal Diagnoses

Screening tests for genetic anomalies have grown significantly in our nation since they became recommended for all pregnant women, regardless of risk, in 2020. The prevalence of these tests has led to an increased number of prenatal diagnoses, some of which are considered life-limiting, and raises important clinical, pastoral, and ethical considerations. The Catholic Church has long stood for the sanctity of every human life from the moment of conception until natural death, and opposes any practice that directly intends the death of an infant or neglects to provide standard care before or after birth. This two-episode series will bring together national experts to discuss concerns about the lack of accurate prognostic information available to parents when a prenatal diagnosis is provided, the impact of prenatal diagnosis on perinatal palliative care, and guidance regarding Catholic ethics. The series will also include best practices in trauma-informed care in supporting parents who receive a prenatal diagnosis and the lived experience of parents who have received such support.

Episode 1:
Monday, October 19, 2026 | 1:00 p.m. EDT

Watch the recording of Episode 1

Featured Panelists

Harrison Headshot

Donna Harrison, M.D., is an obstetrician-gynecologist who is the former CEO, and current Director of Research for the American Association of Pro-life Obstetricians and Gynecologists. She is also the Chair of the Alliance for Hippocratic Medicine, whose principles include protecting the vulnerable at the beginning and end of life, seeking the ultimate good for the patient with compassion and moral integrity, and providing healthcare with the highest standards of excellence based on medical science. The Alliance for Hippocratic Medicine represents over 30,000 medical professionals in the US and Canada.

Dr. Harrison’s peer-reviewed publications include the selective progesterone receptor modulators mifepristone and ulipristal, as well as abortion mortality and morbidity. Dr. Harrison is a Continuing Medical Education speaker internationally on these topics.

Dr. Harrison has served as an adjunct professor at the University of Michigan Medical School in Ann Arbor, Michigan, and Trinity International University in Deerfield, Illinois. She is the mother of 5 children and 14 grandchildren.


McCaffrey Headshot

Marty McCaffrey, M.D., is a Professor of Pediatrics at UNC Chapel Hill in the Division of Neonatal-Perinatal Medicine. He is a retired Captain in the US Navy and served as the Director of Neonatal Care at the Naval Medical Center San Diego and the Consultant to the US Navy Surgeon General for Neonatology. In his current roles at UNC, Dr. McCaffrey is a clinical neonatologist in a Level IV NICU. Dr. McCaffrey is committed to re-establishing a sanctity-of-life ethic in medicine. He is an advocate for families with infants, born and unborn, children, and adults with challenging diagnoses. As a Board Member for the organization Be Not Afraid, Dr. McCaffrey assists in guiding the organization in its mission to formally train parent care coordinators in organizations nationally to support parents dealing with prenatal diagnosis. He is an advisor to the Support Organization for Trisomy (SOFT) and the International Trisomy Alliance. He is a national speaker on the value and need for the lives of the most vulnerable to be lived and respected. He is well published on the subject of care for these invaluable lives, particularly as it relates to individuals with trisomy 13 and 18. In 2024, he published in the National Catholic Bioethics Center’s journal, Ethics and Medics, "The Proper Catholic and Pro-life Response to Life-Limiting Anomalies: Moving Beyond Perinatal Hospice."


Chris Ostertag headshot

Chris Ostertag, Ph.D., serves as the Bill & Lisa Powers Collegiate Associate Professor of the Practice in Preprofessional Studies and the Director of Ethics for the Institute for Rare Diseases at the University of Notre Dame. Prior to Notre Dame, Chris worked as a clinical ethicist and mission leader for seven years across three health systems.

Chris completed a Ph.D. in theology and health care ethics at Saint Louis University, where he wrote a dissertation on "Prenatal Diagnosis, Parenthood, and Disability: A Catholic Call to Witness." Chris also completed an M.A. in philosophy at Texas A&M University and a B.A. in English and Philosophy at Rockhurst University. Chris has published on a variety of topics in bioethics, including prenatal genetic counseling, determination of death and organ donation, disability, data ethics in Catholic health care, and ethics expertise in clinical ethics. Chris is a certified Healthcare Ethics Consultant through the American Society for Bioethics and Humanities.

In addition to his professional experience and education, Chris brings lived experience to his work within the Institute for Rare Diseases. Chris is a bereaved parent of a child who had a rare disease. Chris's son, Hans, had a peroxisomal disorder called Zellweger spectrum disorder. Chris has served on the board of directors for The Global Foundation for Peroxisomal Disorders since 2020 and has been involved in rare disease advocacy since 2017.

At Notre Dame, Chris's research explores ethical issues within the realm of rare disease and how the Catholic social tradition provides an important call for the care and accompaniment of persons and communities impacted by rare disease. Chris is interested in the concept of responsible parenthood in Catholic moral theology, contemporary debates on determination of death and practices surrounding organ donation, organizational ethics issues and Catholic identity in health care, and shared decision-making in pediatrics.


Episode 2:
Tuesday, November 3, 2026 | 12:00 p.m. EST

Watch the recording for Episode 2

Featured Panelists

Milners Headshot

Frank and Catherine Milner have been married for over ten years and have five children, one of whom now intercedes for them in heaven. In 2022, they were served by Be Not Afraid after receiving a prenatal diagnosis of Hypoplastic Left Heart Syndrome (HLHS) for their son, Philip. After being offered termination of the pregnancy three times in one day, they made it their mission to seek out support that was willing to fight for their child alongside them—not to end his life. Be Not Afraid was that support.

Through prenatal visits, Philip’s birth and open-heart surgeries, and the 52 days they had with him before he passed away, Be Not Afraid equipped Catherine and Frank with the knowledge, resources, and support they needed to give Philip a fighting chance at life. Today, Frank and Catherine serve as volunteers for BNA, seeking to share the transformative power of life-affirming support with families facing a prenatal diagnosis.


Pierucci Headshot

Robin Pierucci, M.D., is a board-certified neonatologist and pediatrician with a master’s degree in bioethics. Her clinical practice at Bronson Children’s Hospital’s level III NICU in Kalamazoo, MI began in 2000, where she also was the medical director for 17 years. She led and was involved in multiple performance improvement projects including, care for opiate exposed neonates and improving neurodevelopmental outcomes through decreasing painful stimulation. Dr. Pierucci also is a clinical assistant professor at Western Michigan University Homer-Stryker School of Medicine. Her initial publications involved evaluating using palliative care in the perinatal and neonatal populations. Since then, she has had multiple publications in peer and non-peer reviewed journals and continues to be invited to speak nationally and internationally on an array of perinatal and ethical topics.

In 2024 Dr. Pierucci “retired” from full-time work in the NICU and months later founded Navigating Fetal Concerns, a service devoted to accompanying parents who have received a prenatal diagnosis. This is a continuation of her work with Be Not Afraid, where she remains a medical consultant. Dr. Pierucci also has become the Director of Health Care Initiatives at Voices for the Voiceless.

Dr. Pierucci is a member of the American Academy of Pediatrics, the Catholic Medical Association, an associate scholar with the Charlotte Lozier Institute, and on the Board of Directors for the American College of Pediatricians where she is the co-chair of the pro-life committee.


Judy Townsend Headshot

Judy Townsend began working with Be Not Afraid (BNA) as a member of a parent advisory board developed in 2008. Her youngest child had been prenatally diagnosed with Hypo-Plastic Left Heart Syndrome in 2007. She and her husband, Jim, journeyed through the difficult road of receiving a life-limiting prenatal diagnosis at 19 weeks gestation. With their son, they faced eight different surgical procedures, three of which were open heart surgeries, in a three-year span. Judy knew what it was like to manage a complicated pregnancy, infant surgery and recovery, and many difficult emotional trials without a service of comprehensive support. Her insights were crucial as BNA developed its trauma-responsive model of care for parents. As a result, Judy became BNA’s first Parent Care Coordinator (PCC) when the organization transitioned from peer ministry to a service of comprehensive case management support in 2017 and 2018. In her role as a PCC, she served over 200 couples carrying to term after a prenatal diagnosis, and provided hands-on support at 32 births. Judy offered parents something she and Jim didn’t have: caring, compassionate, and informed care. She was instrumental in the development of BNA’s PCC Training curriculum, and serves as the instructor in several recorded lessons.

Judy has a Bachelor’s degree in Therapeutic Recreation, and she worked with a variety of people with different types of disabilities. This was the beginning of her passion to help others. She and Jim have four children and two deceased children lost to miscarriage. They also have three grandchildren. Judy retired from BNA in 2023 and now spends most of her time with family. She is, however, thrilled to participate in this panel discussion with parents she supported as they carried to term.


This series is co-sponsored by:

de Nicola Center logo Be Not Afraid logo Diocese of Fort Wayne-South Bend crest